Your open rate is up. Your repeat buying is flat. Judge the journey by the second purchase.
A few years ago, at a large membership retailer where I led CRM and membership analytics, I sat in a review meeting for a post-purchase email journey. The team was proud of it.
A few years ago, at a large membership retailer where I led CRM and membership analytics, I sat in a review meeting for a post-purchase email journey. The team was proud of it. Opens were running at just over 50 percent, well above the benchmark the team had looked up. Someone even had the benchmark on a slide: what is a good email open rate for ecommerce? Campaigns average around 31 percent, automated flows around 32 percent, and the best 10 percent get near 45 percent. Our journey sat above all of it.
Then someone asked the question nobody in the room had prepared for. How many of the first-time buyers who got the journey had come back for a second purchase?
The room went quiet. Nobody knew. The journey had been running for months, it had been judged on opens and clicks the whole time, and nobody had ever checked whether it had brought anyone back.
I have seen the same scene play out since, in smaller teams with smaller lists. A founder told me recently that their open rate keeps going up, but clicks and revenue are going down, and they wanted to know what was going on. The answer is usually the same. The team is measuring the inbox, not the customer.
An open measures the inbox, not the customer
An open is recorded when a tiny tracking pixel inside an email loads. That sounds like proof that someone read your message. Since 2021, it is not.
That year, Apple changed how its Mail app handles email. When someone uses Apple Mail, the pixel can load automatically, before the person ever opens the message, sometimes without them opening it at all. The open gets counted either way. For Apple users, recorded opens can run far higher than real opens, with some estimates putting the inflation at 35 to 68 percent.
So a rising open rate can mean three different things. Your subject lines got better. More of your list moved to Apple Mail. Or more of your mail is being opened by software, not people. The dashboard cannot tell you which one it is.
Clicks are a better signal, because a click needs a person to do something. But a click is still not a purchase. It is an intermediate step. The chain is: open, click, buy again. Teams judge the journey on the first two links and never check the third, which is the only one that pays for anything.
The second purchase is the first real sign that a first-time buyer is becoming a repeat customer. It is the number a post-purchase journey exists to move. If the journey does not move it, the journey is not working, however good the open rate looks.
How teams judge journeys now
Most small teams I see judge a lifecycle journey the same way. They open the dashboard, check the open rate and the click rate, and compare them to a benchmark. If opens are up, the journey is a win. If opens dip, someone rewrites subject lines, adds another version, or sends more often.
Almost nobody ties the journey to whether buyers come back inside the window when they would normally buy again. Almost nobody sets a pass or fail line in advance. And almost nobody runs the one check that would settle whether the journey caused anything at all: holding back a small group who never gets the journey, and comparing their second purchase rate with the group who did.
One worked example
Take a small brand with 10,000 first-time buyers entering a post-purchase journey. The journey runs for 60 days, which is the window when these customers would normally buy again.
The dashboard says: 52 percent opened the emails, 2 percent clicked. The team calls it a win. Opens are well above the 31 percent campaign average.
Now count what matters. Out of the 10,000 first-time buyers, 800 buy again within 60 days. That is 8 percent. The team has never measured this number before, so 8 percent means nothing to them on its own.
So run the holdout. Hold back 1,000 first-time buyers who never get the journey at all, and watch them for the same 60 days. They come back at 11 percent.
Read that again. The buyers who never got the journey came back more often than the buyers who did. The journey added nothing. It may even have cost a little, in unsubscribes and in the team's time. But the open rate said it was a win, because the open rate was never measuring the buying. It was measuring the inbox.
What changed
This gap between the inbox number and the buying number used to be a suspicion. It is now documented.
Benchmark pieces published in November 2026 now say plainly that open rate is not a performance benchmark, and should be read next to the click rate at best. And post-purchase sequences now average around 60 percent opens, while most stores still never trigger a second purchase from them. The two numbers sit side by side in the same reports: the inbox number keeps climbing, and the buying number stays flat.
Two things changed underneath. Apple Mail Privacy Protection, in 2021, made opens unreliable in the first place. Then inbox software got better at loading and summarising mail on its own, so more of those recorded opens come from software, not people. The metric keeps getting noisier, and the teams that still judge journeys by it are judging a number that drifts further from buying every year.
What I would do on Monday
Pick one lifecycle journey, the post-purchase one if you have it. Write down its second purchase rate inside your repurchase window, for the buyers who got it and, if you can, for a small group who did not. Decide the wait in advance: 60 days for a product people buy monthly, longer for a slower one. Then call it a pass or a failure.
If the buyers who got the journey come back at a clearly higher rate than the ones who did not, keep it and improve it. If they do not, stop polishing the subject lines and rebuild the journey: the reason to come back, the timing, the offer, the thing that actually makes a first buyer into a second buyer.
An open is a person glancing at a subject line, or software loading a pixel. A second purchase is a customer deciding to come back. Judge the journey by the one that pays you.
This is the kind of work I now do with B2C teams: small, honest checks on what the numbers actually mean, before the team acts on them.
The Repeat Purchase Check, a free 15-minute self-check for B2C and DTC leaders. Five checks that show where repeat buying is leaking, and whether your personalization is doing anything about it: asksaumya-consulting.kit.com/retentioncheck
Sources: Klaviyo benchmarks via Final Practice Digital (2026); Klaviyo Community thread, 'Open rate increasing, but click rate and revenue decreasing' (2026); Apple Mail Privacy Protection (2021); November 2026 benchmark pieces on open rate and post-purchase sequences. The worked example is the author's own illustration with round numbers, not a published case; the opening membership-retailer story is from the author's own practice.